How We Rank Solicitors and Accountants
How a firm gets on our list, what sets its place, and why money has no part in either.
People come to Legal Directorate with something pressing in hand: a separation to sort out, a police interview, a letter from HMRC, or a Self Assessment return due by 31 January. You need to know whether the firms on the page earned their place. This page shows how they did. One rule sits under all of it: no firm pays us, so no firm can buy a better spot.
Our list starts from how clients rated their experience with each firm. It does not predict the outcome of your case or your tax bill, and no list could.
Which firms we list
We begin with the public listings firms keep on maps and search, in every category and town we cover, and we repeat the search on a regular cycle so newly opened firms are found. A firm has to clear these checks to appear, and keep clearing them to stay:
- It is still operating. A firm marked permanently closed comes off our pages.
- It is a real local firm. Call centres and referral networks posing as a local solicitor or accountant are not listed, nor are template websites serving many unrelated "firms".
- One office per town. A firm with several offices in one town appears there once, through the office with the strongest record. A phone number belongs to one listing only.
- Its website works. We visit the website each firm gives us. A dead, parked or taken-over website takes the listing off until it is fixed.
A listing is not proof that a firm is regulated, and neither is anything shown on its profile. We do not check a solicitor's standing with a regulator, or an accountant's membership of a professional body. In England and Wales, the Solicitors Regulation Authority keeps a public register of the solicitors and firms it authorises. In Scotland, solicitors are regulated by the Law Society of Scotland, and in Northern Ireland by the Law Society of Northern Ireland. "Accountant" is not a protected title in the UK, so if chartered or certified status matters to you, check it with the professional body, such as ICAEW, ICAS or ACCA. Scotland and Northern Ireland also have their own legal systems: a solicitor in Carlisle and one in Dumfries answer to different regulators and work under different law, so make sure the firm practises in the one your matter falls under.
What decides the order
Inside each category and town, these rules set the order. A payment or a request never does.
- Client ratings and their number. A 4.7 from 250 clients carries more weight than a 5.0 from four.
- How complete the profile is. Photos, a website, an email address, opening hours and the details a firm states about itself all count, the same way for every firm.
- Location. Firms in the town you searched come first, then firms in nearby towns, closer ones first. Within each group, the points above set the order.
- Best of. A firm holding a Best of award comes first on the page for its own category and town.
Reviews
Reviews come from clients, posted on the firm's public listing. We write none ourselves and accept none sent in by firms. Reviews containing profanity are hidden, private details such as a client's phone number are removed, and text that is not a review, like an ad or a pasted message, is left out. Review counts update at our next check. A review is one client's account of their own matter; it cannot tell you how yours will go.
What a firm can change, and what it cannot
Any firm can claim its listing for free and ask us to correct its hours, phone, areas of law, services and description, or to hide a street address it prefers not to publish, such as a home office. Changes are checked: a description against our editorial rules, a change of firm name by a person. Its reviews and its rating are outside its reach. A complete profile counts the same for every firm, whoever filled it in. No payment or request to us moves a firm up the list.
Best of awards
A Best of award goes to the top firms in a category and town: no more than five, or three where the town has fewer than ten firms in that category. It cannot be bought or traded for a link or a review. Awards are reviewed on a fixed schedule. A holder that closes, changes hands or no longer earns it loses the award to the next firm in line. The award reflects our method and nothing more. No regulator, professional body or court stands behind it, and it says nothing about the result of any matter.
How often we check again
About every three months, roughly once a season, each listing is checked again: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews and photos. Between checks we act on what firms and clients report. If something is wrong, tell us through our Contact us page; we correct errors as soon as we can confirm them.
Read our Independence Policy for how we are funded, and our Editorial Standards for how we check our UK Law Guides.